Chapter 75: Unavoidable Accident

§75.1 Generally

The Case: Whitaker v. Harmon , 879 S.W.2d 865 (Tenn. Ct. App. 1994).

The Basic Facts: Defendant lost control on a wet road and hit plaintiff. He insisted it was error for the trial judge not to give an "unavoidable accident" instruction.

The Bottom Line:

  • "An 'unavoidable accident' has been defined by our courts as follows:
    An unavoidable or inevitable accident is such an occurrence or happening as, under all attendant circumstances and conditions, could not have been foreseen or anticipated in the exercise of ordinary care as the proximate cause of injury by any of the parties concerned. In other words, where there is no evidence that the operator of the motor vehicle was negligent in any way, or that he could have anticipated the resulting accident, the accident is deemed to have been an unavoidable or inevitable one for which no recovery may be had.
    [7A Am. Jur. 2d Automobiles and Highway Traffic § 397, pp. 607-08]; see also [Black's Law Dictionary 1693 (Rev. 4th ed. 1968)]." 879 S.W.2d at 870.
  • "We are aware that there are cases which recite that 'unavoidable accident' is an affirmative defense. See i.e., Nelson v. Simpson, [826 S.W.2d 483 (Tenn. Ct. App. 1991)]. Such assertions, however, are mere dicta. For example, in Nelson, the court simply recited that an answer filed on behalf of the defendant asserted 'the affirmative defenses of unavoidable accident and contributory negligence.' We are further aware that it is not uncommon for trial judges to give an 'unavoidable accident' charge. We believe, however, that since 'unavoidable accident' in its simplest terms is nothing more than a lack of negligence on the part of any party which is a proximate cause of the accident or damage, an adequate instruction on negligence alone is sufficient and an 'unavoidable accident' charge is unnecessary except in, perhaps, the most unusual circumstance. We believe the better view is stated Braden v. Varnell, 871 S.W.2d 690 (1991), (Permission to appeal denied June 10, 1991): [sic]." Id.
  • "As to the last issue, counsel for Mr. Braden insists that sudden emergency is an affirmative defense and Rule 8.03 of the Tennessee Rules of Civil Procedure requires that it be specifically pleaded. Counsel concedes there is a split of authority in other jurisdictions regarding the question. We are inclined to believe that the doctrine is not an affirmative defense because the defenses enumerated in the Rule seek to avoid liability even though a party might otherwise be liable. Under the sudden emergency doctrine a party is guilty of no negligence because of the emergency, and thus there is nothing to avoid." Id.
  • "This reasoning applies equally to the so-called 'unavoidable accident doctrine.' Thus, in accord with Braden, supra, we hold that the defenses of 'sudden emergency' and 'unavoidable accident' are not affirmative defenses, therefore, there was no cause for the trial judge to charge regarding the burden of proof in relation thereto." Id.

Other Sources of Note : Rickets v. Robinson, 169 S.W.3d 642 (Tenn. Ct. App. 2004) (unavoidable accident instruction is no longer necessary but it was not reversible error for the judge to charge it).

After an accident, many injury victims and their families want more information on the accident and their legal rights. Consequently, many of them have found their way to these pages. While we are happy you are here, please understand Day on Torts: Leading Cases in Tennessee Tort Law was written to be a quick, invaluable reference for Tennessee tort lawyers. While the book provides the leading case for more than 300 tort law subjects and thousands of related case citations, it is not a substitute for personalized legal advice from a qualified lawyer.

Rather than researching these legal issues alone, we urge you to contact one of our award-winning lawyers who can sit down with you, review your case, answer your questions and clearly explain your rights and your options in a no-cost, no-obligation consultation. Our experienced attorneys handle all personal injury and wrongful death cases on a contingency basis, so we only get paid if we win. If for any reason you are unable to come to our office, we will gladly come to you.

To schedule an appointment, contact us online or call us at 615-742-4880 or toll-free at 866-812-8787.



The foregoing is an excerpt from Day on Torts: Leading Cases in Tennessee Tort Law, published by John A. Day, Civil Trial Specialist, Fellow in the American College of Trial Lawyers, recipient of Best Lawyers in America recognition, Martindale-Hubbell AV® Preeminent™ rated attorney, and Top 100 Tennessee Mid-South Super Lawyers designee. Read John’s full bio here.

To order a copy of the book, visit www.dayontortsbook.com. John also blogs regularly on key issues for tort lawyers. To subscribe to the Day on Torts blog, visit www.dayontorts.com.

Client Reviews
Everything was great. You guys are a great representative. I was satisfied with everything. Truly appreciate John Day and his hard-working staff.
★★★★★
We thought that you did an excellent job in representing us in our lawsuit. We would recommend you to anyone. Mitch Deese
★★★★★
The Law Offices of John Day is, without a doubt, the best in Nashville! They treated me with the utmost respect and tended to my every need. No question went unanswered. I was always kept informed of every step in the process. I received phenomenal results; I couldn't ask for more. I would definitely hire the Law Offices of John Day again. Anthony Santiago
★★★★★
I would definitely recommend to anyone to hire John Day's law firm because everyone was helpful, made everything clear and got the job done. I am satisfied with how my case was handled. June Keomahavong
★★★★★
It's been a long battle but this firm has been very efficient and has done a remarkable job for me! I highly recommend them to anyone needing legal assistance. Everyone has always been very kind and kept me informed of all actions promptly. Linda Bush
★★★★★
I had a great experience with the Law Offices of John Day. The staff was very accommodating, and my phone calls/emails were always responded to in a timely manner. They made the entire process very easy and stress-free for me, and I had confidence that my case was in good hands. I am very happy with the results, and I highly recommend! Casey Hutchinson
★★★★★